Horsham Downs Bakery is a bakery at 2/148 Horsham Downs Road in Rototuna, Hamilton. It holds a Google rating of 4.9 from 39 reviews, and reviewers often mention the pies, especially the paua pie and the potato top pie. Some visitors say the flaky pastry and the sausage rolls are also worth trying.
A pie shop is judged first on its pastry, which should be flaky and hold its shape, and on a filling that is full without being greasy. Potato top pies need a smooth, even layer that matches the filling underneath. Pies sell fast at lunch and late in the day, so arriving early gives the widest choice. When choosing a bakery in a growing suburb like Rototuna, look at the pies on display and ask which ones were made that morning.
For a paua pie or a potato top pie in Rototuna, it is a bakery worth a stop on Horsham Downs Road.